Focus on the Family Broadcast   >>   All Episodes

The Joys and Challenges of Marrying Your Opposite

Original Air Date 07/15/2014

Get Social and Listen

Author Melanie Shankle offers a humorous look at the differences between men and women, and explains how couples can work through those differences to strengthen their marriage.

Listen here, watch recent episodes on our YouTube channel, or download our app.

Episode Transcript



Woman: I like black coffee.

Man: Sugar and cream.

Woman: I don’t mind sour things.

Man: I have the world’s biggest sweet tooth.

Woman: I’m a saver.

Man: I’m a spender.

Woman: I’m a planner.

Man: I’m impulsive.

Woman: When I’m lost, I’ll ask directions quickly.

Man: Asking directions is a sign of weakness.

End of Teaser

John Fuller: (Chuckling) Well, I wonder if you ever feel like that couple there? You’re married and you love each other, but there are some things you are just on way different pages over. And uh … that’s really our subject on today’s Focus on the Family — how to navigate those differences and have some fun with them. Our host is Focus president and author, Jim Daly. I’m John Fuller and Jim, I’m lookin’ forward to the discussion.

Jim Daly: Uh … so am I, John. You know, it’s so funny listening to that clip. Opposites do attract. Uh … I know it’s not everybody’s scenario and uh … don’t bother writing on that. We know that there are some couples that are very similar and we get it. But usually it’s opposites that do attract. I don’t know God’s chemistry there and what He put in us as human beings to be attracted to someone who thinks differently. I think it’s a good thing, but it does create some very humorous moments (Chuckling)--

John: It does.

Jim: --that’s for sure.

John: Absolutely and it seems, Jim, that those differences get accentuated with the years. I don’t know, that’s my personal experience.

Jim: I can remember when Jean and I did our premarital counseling when we went in. We went in, you know, goo-goo-eyed and we were saying, “We’re so much alike. We like all the same things.

John: Ahh, sweet.

Jim: And we sat through a week’s worth of, you know, like every night of premarital counseling. And we walked out of there at the end going, “We are so different. Oh … are we gonna be okay?” And that’s a good thing for premarital counseling, because you want to be tested that you really are committed to each other, regardless of your differences, not your similarities.

And uh … you know what? Here at Focus on the Family we want to help you with that if uh … you’re not married yet and you’re thinkin’, who would be right, we have resources to help you. If you’re married and you’re thinkin’, uh-oh; have I made a mistake, we want to certainly be there for you in that circumstance, to uh … give you some help and to put an arm around you and make sure that God’s in control and that you can make it through it.

John: Uh-hm. And we have a guest today who will say that very thing. She is married to an opposite and uh … it’s Melanie Shankle and she’s been a guest on this broadcast before. She’s delightful. 

She’s the founder of the popular Big Mama blog. (Laughter) and author of the … the book, The Antelope in the Living Room: The Real Story of Two People Sharing One Life. And she lives with her husband and opposite, Perry, and their daughter, Caroline, in the San Antonio, Texas area. 


Jim: Melanie, it’s great to have you back at Focus on the Family.

Melanie Shankle: Thank you. It’s great to be here.

Jim: Okay, let’s start right there. I mean, the whole thing about the antelope in the living room.

Melanie: (Laughing) Yeah.

Jim: I’m assuming uh … that’s a … a stuffed antelope head, but what’s goin’ on--

Melanie: It is.

Jim: --with that title?

Melanie:  You are correct. You’re correct. My husband, my sweet husband is a hunter and loves to hunt. And we’ve had deer heads in our living room, which I (Laughter)… I’m fine with. I mean, we … we have. I mean …

Jim: That sounds a little odd.

Melanie: Yeah.

John: Many women would not be fine with that. 

Melanie:  Well, but you know, we’re in Texas and that’s part of it and I knew it when I married him, it was part of the deal. And so, we’ve had those things. 

But there was a time, I was out of town and I knew he had gone on this hunt months before and … and shot a Nilgai antelope. Um … which a Nilgai antelope, if you … I’m gonna give you a picture in your head, kind of looks like a huge cow with horns, is what it looks like. (Laughter) It …

Jim: I’ve seen a cow with horns before.

Melanie:  Yeah, well, it’s …

Jim: But they go up in the air--

Melanie:  They kinda go up--

Jim:  --kinda straight up, not out.

Melanie:  --in the air, but straight up. It’s ju … it’s not the prettiest thing you’ll ever see; that’s what I’m gonna tell you. A Nilgai antelope, you can look it … look it up on Google. But it um … he had shot one. Well, I never thought to ask what did you do with it or whatever. I knew that we ate the meat, because that’s what we do, eat what he shoots. And so, I knew that we had done that. Well, I had gone on a trip right before Thanksgiving with some girlfriends. And … 

Um … when I got home that day I walked into the house and there was … I can’t even describe it to you, a huge Nilgai antelope head hanging right next to my front door in my living room. It looked like the thing had been running down the block and crashed through (Laughter) the front of our house. It was … there it was.Jim: It was that big. It kinda looked like a cow with horns.

Melanie:  Exactly. (Laughter) That’s … yeah, yeah. I’ve heard; they look like a cow with … it was enormous. I can’t even tell you how big this thing is. (Laughter) I mean, it’s like a 2,000 pound animal.

Jim: So, I gotta ask you, all of a sudden, were you happy or sad?

Melanie:  No, I looked at him and I said, “I don’t understand why you hate our house (Laughter) and why you would do that?” And I … I don’t understand. Like we live in a small little cottage house. We don’t live in some big ranch house that lends itself to big animals hangin’ on the wall. I mean, this thing was a monstrosity.

And so, I said, “I … I … I don’t even know what to do.” Well, he was angry and so I left because it really was one of those moments that ended with us really not speakin’ to each other for like two days.

John: So he--

Melanie:  And I thought …

John: --he’s got this trophy that shows--

Melanie:  That he’s so--

John: --he …

Melanie:  --proud of--

John: Yes.

Melanie: --that I hate and I don’t want in our living room. And I thought, this is one of those things. And that’s when I thought, if I ever write a book on marriage, I’m gonna call it The Antelope in the Living Room, because--

Jim: Oh, that’s good.

Melanie:  --these are the proverbial “antelopes in the living room” and the literal antelopes in the living room that um … cause some friction and tension in marriage.

Jim: Well, I gotta ask the question then. Is it still hangin’ in the living room?

John: Oh, yeah.

Melanie:  Well, I will tell you, it did for a long time. It did for a long time.  That …

Jim: Uh … does that mean a few weeks or a few years?

Melanie:  No, no, a few years.

Jim: Okay.

Melanie:  That Christmas it loomed over our Christmas tree.

Jim: You could hang decorations from those horns.

Melanie:  Well, I … it-

Jim: That’s the beauty of it.

Melanie:  --had … it wore … wore a Santa hat. It …

John: Functional.

Melanie:  Yeah, it--

Jim: Yeah.

Melanie:  --wore a Santa hat and a Rudolf’s nose. (Laughter) I mean, it … it was dressed up. But every time I would walk in the living room, because this … the way this thing loomed, I would be like, “And lo, an antelope of the Lord appeared.” (Laughter) Because it just (Laughter) … it just hovered. (Laughter)

Jim:Uh … talk about that, the differences. Why do you think God um … puts that in us to be attracted to someone that doesn’t think the way we think? Is it to get rid of our selfishness?

Melanie: (Chuckling) I think that’s a part of it. I think it’s to get rid of your selfishness. And I think it’s to … to just kind of refine each other. You know, I just … especially as Perry and I have been married, you know, longer and longer , I just see in so many aspects, whether it’s parenting or in social settings or you know, whatever it is, that we just … our strengths and weaknesses are really designed to complement each other. I mean the places where I tend to, you know, have weaknesses and maybe not stand up for myself or maybe not say no or overcommit, you know, that’s where Perry’ll come in and be like, “You just need to tell ‘em no. I’ll tell ‘em no for you.” (Laughter) You know, it’s … it’s that and it helps bal … we … it balances us out. And I think God does that to create, I mean, you know, the two become one and ideally that’s one balanced person. And I think that works well when you’ve got your different strengths and weaknesses …

Jim: It can also create great tension.

Melanie: Oh, for sure.

Jim: And uh … it may not come out in the nice (Clearing throat) phase of your relationship (Laughter), perhaps the dating phase (Clearing throat) you kinda look right through. You may be blind to it.

Melanie: Uh-hm, yes.

Jim: Um … shortly after marriage, somewhere along the line, first year, third year, fifth year, those things become more irritants. How … how do we as married people manage that better, understand that and look, you’re not gonna be able to control the person you married. You want to become one flesh, but you’ve got to be able to take a deep breath and realize that God has created your mate in a different way than He created you.

Melanie: Uh-hm. I think, you know, one of the things I told myself early on uh … in marriage and after Perry and I got married and I realized we were different in so many ways. And sometimes I didn’t understand what his priorities were or especially, you know, when it comes to money, which is a whole other thing, how we want to spend money and what we thought was important and all those different things that I thought I really want to treat him … um … the way I would treat my best friend.

And it was that realization of I should be treating my husband with that same kindness and that same sense of forgiveness, because I realized I was so much more willing to overlook things in my best girlfriend than I was in my husband. And I was holding him to a higher standard that ultimately I thought, that’s not … that’s not fair. I mean, he’s also my best friend in a different way, you know and just that I need to treat him with that kindness and understanding of who he is and … and what’s important to him. 

Jim: Okay, a lot of people just went, “Yeah! That’s it! That’s, that... I’ve got to share that with my wife tonight!” (Laughter) Uh, any disclaimers to hear that, I mean?

Melanie: (Chuckling) Well, I mean, I think that there’s give and take. And they’ve got to do the same thing back. But, I think if you can get that mutual respect of you know what, I may not understand this, but I’m gonna respect it. It’s important to you. 

And then if you give that to each other, then I think it creates a nice give-and-take, and a compromise, which is, ultimately, what marriage is about.

Jim: Now looking back when you and Perry were courting each other--

Melanie: Uh-hm.

Jim: --first of all, tell us a bit about how that came about, given that you’re kinda opposite. Uh … but how did that come about? And did you not see those things in that context until after you were married?

Melanie: You know, I think that it’s interesting. We both were at Texas A&M. We met at a Bible study there called Breakaway. And we just were friends, you know, just mutual acquaintances.  And then we both ended up in San Antonio after graduation and that was when we were reintroduced and … and met at that time. And I knew, you know, he was kind of different to me. I mean his family had grown up with ranches and he was an outdoorsman. His dad had been a big outdoorsman. 

And so, that was such a part of his life. My family’s idea of an outdoor activity is golf, at best. (Laughter) I mean, that’s … that’s about where we rough it on the golf course, maybe the tennis court sometimes, but you know, that was …

John: You don’t have a cart.

Melanie: No--

John: That’s--

Melanie: --no. (Laughter)

John: --roughing it, right?

Melanie: Yeah, that’s it; that’s it. That’s e …

Jim: And nothin’ that goes “bang.”

Melanie: Yeah, no … no guns, no you know … and so, I knew that was part of his … and I loved it. You know, to me it was interesting to go down there and … and go to the ranch and … and see wild hogs and deer and this whole world that I didn’t really even know existed, even though I grew up in Texas, too. I just had such a different city upbringing.

But you know, I think in the way that girls do, you tend to be more into all those differences when you’re dating, you know. (Laughter) It was kinda like, oh, I would love to get up at 5 a.m. and hunt with you. Tell me more about that. (Laughter) And now, you … you know, you couldn’t pay me to get up at 5 a.m. and go hunt with him. But you know, when you’re dating, you’re willing to, you know, take one for the team a little bit. (Laughter) So uh … (Laughter) and then it’s later. Maybe it’s a bait and switch. Maybe it’s not fair of us.

Jim: Well, I was gonna say, that sounds like bait and switch--

Melanie: Yeah.

Jim: --perfect.

Melanie: A little bit, a little bit. But …

Jim: It’s accommodation.

Melanie: It is; it is. And now, you know, I’ll still go out and hunt sometimes, but it just requires … I need to bring my magazines with me and the temperature needs to be just right and I need to be preferably in a blind that doesn’t have bugs and you know.

Jim: And a heater.

Melanie: And a heater (Laughter), for sure. And … but other--

Jim: Other …

Melanie: --than that …

Jim: A microwave, it always--

Melanie: --yeah.

Jim: --helps to warm up your latte.

Melanie: Other than that, I’m like a pioneer. (Laughter) Other … (Laughter)

Jim: Hey, when you talk about that realization that maybe we’re different, I think you have a story in your book on your honeymoon--

Melanie: Yeah. (Laughs)

Jim: --Where that … that difference came out. You thought it would be what? And then what did Perry expect out of your honeymoon?

Melanie: Well, there were a whole lot of things, but I will tell you that the biggest of what stood out to me was when we got on the plane. You know, we were goin’ to the Bahamas and we were gonna be at a resort for a week. And so, I brought a book, because I’m a reader. That’s what I love to do. And so, I brought a nice … I mean, I had researched, you know, to find …

Jim:Moby Dick or something--

Melanie: Oh, well, I didn’t …

Jim: --get you through a week.

Melanie: You know, something like that, (Laughter) you know. Some … it was probably … you know, who knows? But I had brought a book and we got on the plane for our first leg of our flight and we got all settled in and … and I opened up my book, you know. And we’d already at that point been together for 24 hours, so you know, you … you rehashed the wedding and you talked. And so, I was ready to read my book. 

Melanie: And he said, “What are you doin’?” And I said, “Well, I’m … I’m reading.” And I said, “Did you bring anything to read?” And he pulled out a Cabela’s catalogue. (Laughter)

John: This is an outdoors--

Melanie: Yeah, an outdoors--

John: --outdoors place.

Melanie: --outdoors catalogue.

Jim: I like this guy.

Melanie: Yeah. He pulls it out and he thumbs through it and the plane, you know, they hadn’t even … I don’t even think everybody was even on board yet and he said, “Well, I’m done with that. What now?” And (Laughter) I was like, “Do you not read?” And he was like, “Not really; I don’t like to read books.” And I just … (Laughter) it was that moment of, we’ve dated for two years, like you would’ve thought that would’ve come up, but it just goes to …

Jim: It didn’t cover that, huh?

Melanie: We never … we never covered that. 

And to this day, he’s like, well, you can just tell me about your book. So it was that whole thing of, then we were on a three-hour flight and I read on flights. That’s what I do. But all of a sudden, he was that passenger that you hate to sit next to, because they (Laughter) want to talk--

John: The whole time.

Melanie: --instead of lettin’ you read your book.

Jim: Hang on. Did you call you mom and said, “I met the most horrible passenger on the plane. (Laughter) Unfortunately, he’s my new husband.”

Melanie: Yes, my new husband, who doesn’t like to read. So, you know, librarians and barbarians, somethin’ like that. (Laughter) So …

John: There’s the Sky Mall catalogue.

Melanie: Yeah, well, that’s it.

John: He can always order from that.

Melanie: Well, that’s …

 Jim: Some--

Melanie: Yeah, he had--

Jim: --experience there.

Melanie: --some options. He had some options. I think we ended up doin’ like a crossword puzzle and maybe some of that, you know, Sudoku, kind of--

Jim: Oh, yeah.

Melanie: --which I can’t do, but I pretended.

Jim: It’s so funny. And I know for Jean and I, it’s funny ‘cause she was a night person and I was a morning person. That was--

Melanie: Uh-hm.

Jim: --our big distinction.

Melanie: Uh-hm.

Jim: And you know, having children changes that for a woman and she has learned to accommodate early mornings and--

Melanie: Yes.

Jim: --late evenings. So, she’s everything now. But when we were first married, that … she would not talk before 10 o’clock.

Melanie: Yes! (Laughs) 

Jim: I mean, literally, I thought she was mad at me every morning. (Laughter) ‘Cause I … I wake up bubbly--

Melanie: Uh-huh.

Jim: --ready to go. (Laughter) Well, let’s go conquer the day. Let’s … let’s pray, you know. Let’s ask--

Melanie: Uh-hm.

Jim: --the Lord to give us that strength. And “Uh-buh-buh-buh-buh …”

Melanie: Yeah (Laughing)

Jim: And then at night I’d be, “Uh-buh-buh-buh …” And she’s--

Melanie: Uh-hm.

Jim: --all, “Hey, let’s … let’s have some--

John: Let’s talk.

Jim: --prayer time.” I’m going, “You know, if I bow my head, I think I might fall asleep.”

Melanie: Yes! Yes.

Jim: And uh … it’s just the way we’re wired, isn’t it?

Melanie: It is; it is.

Jim: How do you find that middle ground where you can say, okay, here’s where we can meet?

Melanie: You know, I think it takes a while to find your rhythm. I mean, we had that same thing, night owl, early mornin’, you know, Perry’s an early bird; I’m a night owl. 

And I think it just takes some adjusting and adapting and figurin’ out what’s important. And you know, and I learned early on, he didn’t care if I slept until 10 o’clock on weekends. You know, he’s … he’s fine with that and I didn’t care if he got up early.

Jim: Oh, he’s gracious--

Melanie: It … he is. (Laughter) Now--

Jim:  --(Chuckling) you know.

Melanie: --now notice this is--

Jim: Is he a--

Melanie: --pre-kids.

Jim: --morning guy?

Melanie: This was pre-kids. He is a morning guy.

Jim: Yeah, see that’s pretty good. Morning guys like that. You … we usually want you up, you know, by 8.

Melanie: Yeah. No, he’s learned. Now at first, I think, ‘cause he grew up in a home where his mom got up and cooked him breakfast. And I was just like, you know, here … so, it was kinda like the reading thing for me.

Jim: Cheerios?

Melanie: Where it was like, you know, I don’t … I don’t cook breakfast. Here’s the thing - I don’t cook breakfast. I don’t believe in it. (Laughter) Um... it’s uh, you know. 

John: You’re on your own. 

Jim: And... and how’d that... 

Melanie: You’re on your own.

Jim: --how’d that go down?

Melanie: You’re on your own.

John: Go out and kill something for breakfast.

Melanie: Yeah, exactly. Go scavenge. You’re a hunter. Go scavenge--

Jim: What that good?

Melanie: --for breakfast?

Jim: Did that work well?

Melanie: Um … you know, it worked out. I mean, he figured out. He was in charge of breakfast. That’s what he did. And I think that so much of marriage is, it’s figuring out here’s a hill I’m willing to die on and here’s something that I can let go and compromise on and--

Jim: Boy, that’s well-said.

Melanie: --figuring out the balance. 

Jim: I think a lot of times that friction in marriage is wrapped right around that. There’s no solution. You get bitter. You start resenting your spouse and you don’t find [a] solution. You don’t have a desire anymore.

Melanie: Uh-hm.

Jim: And then the relationship just becomes so brittle that nobody wants to invest in it any longer. And then you’ll end up in counseling or on your way to divorce court--

Melanie: Uh-hm.

Jim: --even within the Christian community.

Melanie: Uh-hm.

Jim: Um … for you, what … what’s a sign that you need help? I mean, when you’re there and you’re in that situation, the opposites and the humor is perhaps--

Melanie: Uh-hm.

Jim: --no longer there.

Melanie: Yeah.

Jim: And now it’s become more like battle.

Melanie: Uh-hm.

Jim: What does a woman do particularly? Speak to that woman in that situation.

Melanie: You know, I think that’s … it’s hard. I … I … you know, for me, that’s when I really began to pray and I … and I’ve just learned over the years that sometimes the trick is to act like I’m still in love even if I don’t feel like I’m still in love. You know, I think feelings can be so... deceitful. You know, I think your feelings can lead you astray and you can just start to think, “Well, I don’t feel it. And so, if I don’t feel it, then I’m not gonna act on it. And so, I’m gonna quit doin’ these acts of kindness or these things that I’ve done.” And sometimes I’ve learned if I’ll just ask the Lord to give me strength to just kinda power through and to still um … treat Perry the way that I know he wants to be treated and to … to respect him and to love him and to encourage him, even if I don’t necessary feel it. 

Um … but a lot of times I feel like it comes back around. Sometimes it’s just workin’ through. And I think that, you know, what you learn in bein’ married for any amount of time is … I mean, there are highs and lows. I mean, I feel like, you know, I could go back over our marriage and if you looked at a map, there were probably years that looked like mountaintops and there are years that looked like valleys. 

And you know, both of those, I mean, if you can find a good level and sometimes that’s just continuing to just love each other and encourage each other, even if you don’t feel it in that moment.” Because I think things take place and you know, with a woman, I know you can have a million things on your mind. You’re worried about your finances. You’re worried about what’s gonna be for dinner. You’re worried about how you kids are doin’ in school. You’re worried about your … You know, your community and your friends and your church and your Bible study group and … and it’s hard to not let all those things pile up to where you lose sight of your marriage. But it’s just to continue to make that a priority and just ask God to give you the strength, because sometimes you’re not gonna feel it and it’s only gonna be by trusting Him and … and letting Him guide you through that path.

John: Well, we’re hearing some excellent advice and having some laughs along the way as we talk to Melanie Shankle on today’s Focus on the Family with Jim Daly. I’m John Fuller and Melanie’s book is The Antelope in the Living Room. And we’ve got details about that at

And if we’re touching on something that you’re just really struggling with, if these differences are really glaring and irritating and you’re struggling with that, give us a call here. We have caring Christian counselors and we’d be happy to at least have an initial conversation with you to kinda get you going down the right path. And our number here is 800, the letter A and the word FAMILY.

Jim: Melanie, I so appreciate your humor and your heart (Chuckling). Um … let’s touch on the really sticky issue—in-laws.

Melanie: (Laughter)

Jim: Talk about your experience with Perry. And I think it was a holiday you guys were comin’ together and you were just married, right?

Melanie: Yes. We had just been married. 

Melanie: In-laws are such a tricky thing (Laughter) and I think that’s such a … I’ll have to be careful, ‘cause my mother-in-law’s probably listening. Um …

Jim: Well, you’re talking generically--

Melanie:  Yeah.

Jim: --or about your friend, Sue.

Melanie:  Yeah, well, that’s right; that’s right. And I love my mother-in-law. But it’s so hard, because you’ve got two different families that have been two different ways and you know. And … and sometimes you’re just different. 

And what I had learned, my husband’s um … for the first Thanksgiving I spent with his family or one of the first—I had been with them a couple of Thanksgivings, but this was after we were married—and I felt … his mom does a very traditional Thanksgiving. It is turkey and dressing and green beans and rolls.

Jim: Sounds good to me.

Melanie:  And that’s it. (Laughter) But I like variety. I came from where everybody brought all these different dishes and there was green bean casserole and there was broccoli rice casserole and there was sweet potato casserole. And I decided I missed the variety. 

So, I took it upon myself that I was gonna create a little of that at the next Thanksgiving. And so, I’d called my mother-in-law and asked her if I could bring anything and she told me no. And I said, “Well, I would really like to bring broccoli rice casserole, because it’s my favorite and I miss it at holidays.” And so, she’s gracious, and said that would be great.

Well, my husband has a brother that’s seven years younger than him. And so, at the time was, you know, in his 20s. And so, I brought this, my broccoli rice casserole and I set it in the middle and his brother, “Ew, what is that?” (Laughter) And I was like, “Well, it’s broccoli rice casserole.” And he was like, “It smells. What is that smell?” And I was like, “Well, it’s … it’s got Cheez-Whiz in it. It’s Cheez-Whiz.” And it was just … they were all …

Jim: Cheez Whiz?

Melanie:  Well (Laughter), what are you puttin’ Cheez Whiz in there?

Melanie:  And … have you never had it--

Jim: I’ve never had--

John: Oh, I used to …

Melanie:  --with cream of--

Jim: --yours.

Melanie:  —mushroom soup? Well …

John: Obviously, we’ll have to post the recipe for this on the website.

Jim: Broccoli--

Melanie:  I mean, it’s …

Jim: --yeah, there you go.

Melanie:  Listen, it’s everything that--

Jim: Cheez Whiz? (Laughter)

Melanie:  --you … and … and cream of mushroom soup. It’s everything--

John: Of course.

Melanie:  --you shouldn’t eat, but it makes the broccoli delicious. (Laughter) I mean …

Jim: Obviously it gives an--

John: You cover it up.

Jim: --odor.

Melanie:  It gives it a little … well, Cheez Whiz has a little bit of a … I mean, it’s … it’s cheese in a jar with a--

Jim: Okay.

Melanie:  --long shelf life.

Jim: So, you showed up with this delicious traditional dish of your family.

Melanie:  Well, yes, and I was very excited. It was the food of my people--

Jim: Did anybody--

Melanie:  --like the Indians brought.

Jim:  --else … did anybody else jump in at this point?

Melanie:  No, nobody else, not even--

Jim: Including your husband.

Melanie:  --even my husband.

John: You’re standing alone. (Laughter)

Melanie:  No, I was … I was a woman alone with my broccoli rice casserole. I said, it was as if I had plopped a dead rat in the middle of the table and said, “Here you go. I hope you all enjoy it.” Nobody …

Jim: So, this was Perry’s moment to step up, but he didn’t. How’d--

Melanie:  It was.

Jim: --that make you feel?

Melanie:  I know. Well, and I don’t know that he didn’t step up. I’m tryin’ to remember. I knew he wouldn’t necessarily--

John: You’d remember if he did.

Melanie:  --eat it. I know. (Laughter) I know. I don’t … I think it was kinda like a … it was like nobody mentioned it. It was … it was … it was the broccoli rice casserole in the living room, I guess.

Jim: Did you bring that next--

Melanie:  It was …

Jim: --the next year?

Melanie:  I didn’t.

Jim: Did you … ?

Melanie:  I haven’t brought it back since. (Laughter) Now I just make it for myself. I eat it in the privacy of my home and you know. So, it is what--

John: It’s her comfort food.

Melanie:  --it is. It is; it’s my comfort food. Nobody appreciated the Cheez Whiz, but …

Jim: That is so funny!

Melanie:  Yeah, it’s just a different taste. 

Jim: Hey, uh … you talk in your book about that idea of commitment to your vows. And you know, in this culture today, uh … it’s like a corporate slogan now, you know, “We care.”

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: Or “the customer’s first.” We kinda take our marital vows in that same way. Yeah, they sound great--

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: --but we really don’t have to live up to them. Um … you’re sayin’, no. I mean, there are things in that commitment that are holy, that are sacred--

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: --when it comes to this idea of “through sickness or in health.”

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: Um … how have you had to deal with that in your marriage?

Melanie:  I … with marriage, it’s just … you do say those vows. You know, and it’s just part of what you say and I think everybody can repeat the marriage vows and we know what they are. 

But what you’re really doin’ is, you’re … you’re taking on that person. I mean, you’re … the two are becoming one and … and if everyone would look at that before you ever get into marriage to realize, what a commitment that is and what you’re … what you’re vowing to do. I mean, because you don’t know what life is gonna throw your way. And I think that’s what Perry and I have seen over our years of marriage, is you know, you say those things, but you don’t know what “in sickness and in health” means until one of you actually gets sick and you’ve gotta take care of ‘em and… 

You know, you don’t know what it means in, you know, “for better or for worse.” I mean, when that person is kind of unlovable and you don’t like ‘em much that day, but that you’re gonna stay committed anyway. And it’s … it’s so much beyond just a heart thing. It’s gotta be a head thing to … to stay engaged and to remember that you made a commitment before your family and before God and that you’re gonna honor those vows. Because I think the world tells us that it can be disposable and you can walk away when it’s not working.

 Uh … but I think that’s such a lie, because you know, having come from a divorced home, I mean, you realize how so much of that is um … divorce may seem like an easy solution, but you’re ul … ultimately openin’ yourself to just a whole other set of issues and problems and … and things and it’s not always … it’s not gonna be the easiest solution.

Jim: Hm. Now did Perry have some issues or … or did you have issues? Wh … how do you speak from experience in that regard?

Melanie: Well, one of the biggest things is, with um … when we were … Perry has had some back issues. He’s had some back problems, so uh … 

Jim: Carrying all that antelope.

Melanie: Well, it is; it’s carrying the antelope, (Laughter) which you … you say, but I think there’s some truth to that. If you’re gonna continually hoist up, you know, a 200-lb. deer, at some point, you may have … and you know, men aren’t known for, you know, being smart about sometimes the way they lift things, ‘cause they’re gonna show off their raw brute strength, you know. So, there’s …

Jim: It helps around your friends.

Melanie: That’s it; that’s it. (Laughter) So, um … but Perry had some back problems and so, he’s had three different back surgeries since we’ve been married.

Jim and John: Hm.

Melanie: And it is that thing of, there’s something very kind of sobering about watchin’ them get your husband prepped in pre-op and knowin’ that he’s goin’ back and you know that it’s supposed to be a routine surgery. But it’s … it’s his health and you know, and he has a landscape business. We’re very dependent on his physical health for, you know--

Jim: Uh-hm.

Melanie: --his income and his job and … and you just realize, this is a different deal. Like everybody’s … you know, even his family is now lookin’ to me. I’m the one in charge of his health care. I’m the one in charge of like making sure that he’s gonna be taken care of and that this is gonna be all right and … and findin’ him the … the you know, the help he needs--

Jim: Hm.

Melanie:  --to get better.

Jim: So true. I remember when I broke my ankle from a motorcycle accident--

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: --which we won’t talk too much about.

Melanie:  Yeah (Laughing).

Jim: But uh … a friend of mine … ‘cause I was you know, had to stay off it, certainly--

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: --for the first few weeks. I was in bed. You know, I did make it into the office on crutches a couple of times. But they really wanted me off it for that first week--

Melanie:  Uh-hm. 

Jim: --Or two. And uh … I can remember a friend brought over (Chuckling) partly as a sense of humor, he brought over a bell--

Melanie:  Oh, yeah.

Jim: --that I could ring.

Melanie:  Uh-huh.

Jim: And I remember when he brought it over, the scowl that (Laughter) that Jean had on her face. (Laughter) I mean, it was not well received by my … by my wife.

Melanie:  Uh-hm. yeah.

Jim: She thought that was a little bit rude.

Melanie:  Yeah.

Jim: Uh … but you know, she was so great.

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: And you know, when you can’t get up, if you think about this, laying there and you can’t get up--

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: --for a drink of water.

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: You’ve gotta constantly throughout the day say, “Honey, can I have another glass of water?”

Melanie:  Yes.

Jim: That can really get on you.

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: And--

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: --she was so good about that and just all the little things that she did.

Melanie:  Yes.

Jim: But that’s an illustration of what you gotta do in that moment.

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: And I know some couples are suffering, ‘cause it’s … it’s prolonged; it’s chronic--

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: --whatever that--

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: --ailment might be.

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: And you can grow weary in that, but--

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

Jim: --I think the Lord is pleased and has a smile on His face when you can show His character in that situation.

Melanie:  Yes, yes, I think that’s true. And I think that’s just … it … it’s a tangible way of showing your love for that person, you know, that I’m willing to serve you and be here and … and I want to walk you through this.

Jim: Hm.

John: Those circumstances are always reminders, too that it doesn’t always turn out the way we planned. I mean--

Melanie:  No.

John: --we … we … you enter into marriage. You’re both strong and vi … --

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

John: --typically strong and vibrant.

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

John: And those corners come and that’s kind of the test.

Melanie:  Uh-hm.

John: What is this really all about? 

Melanie:  Yeah and I think that’s so true. And I mean, I think we experienced that when I went through my miscarriage um … years ago and it was just such a hard time for me emotionally and physically and everything. And … and for me, at that point, we’d been married five years, but I always look back at that point and think, it was the first time that I realized almost the depth of how much Perry loved me and cared for me, because I wasn’t his happy smiling wife. You know, I’m generally an upbeat person, but that he loved me when I was in bed and depressed and … and couldn’t get up. And that he walked me through that and encouraged me. And sometimes you need those moments in marriage, ‘cause I think they … they knit you together a little bit deeper when you’ve been through somethin’ hard together. 


John: Melanie Shankle has been our guest on Focus on the Family. And as we mentioned earlier, if your marriage is going through some rough times and you need extra help, please contact us. Our Counseling team is available to pray with you, and they’ll have an initial consult with you over the phone and then direct you to some resources in your area. The number is 800-232-6459. 800, the letter A, and the word FAMILY. And please, don’t hesitate to call us. 

Jim: That’s why we’re here folks. Uh, we’re doing everything we can to strengthen, and even rescue your marriage, if necessary. Let us help you. We have got lots of great resources, like Melanie’s funny and meaningful book, The Antelope in the Living Room. And our marriage assessment is right there, online. Uh, you can take that, free of cost, and it will show you where your strengths, and areas to improve your relationship, are at, and also make some suggestions on resources and tools that could improve those less-strong areas.

And of course, these resources do cost money. And we rely upon you to strengthen those relationships around you, and to do it through Focus on the Family. In fact, if you’re able to send us a financial gift of any amount today we will gladly send you a complimentary copy of Melanie’s book. That is our way of saying “Thank you for helping support marriage today.” 

John: We’d love to hear from you! And our number, again, is 800-A-FAMILY. Or donate at And uh, when you get in touch, be sure to ask about a CD or download of today’s broadcast. And be sure, as well, to get the app for your smartphone or tablet so you can listen on the go! 

Coming up next time on this broadcast, how to raise a financially-wise young adult . . .!


Pastor Chris Brown: I’m convinced there’s not a student loan crisis in America. Yeah, prices are high. There’s not a student loan crisis in America, there’s a parenting crisis in America. (Jim: Huh.) And again, not condemnation but, man, let’s not let our kids get into that.

End of Teaser


  • Featured MP3

    Free Audio Download: "Discovering Your Love Style"

    Focus on the Family

    Milan and Kay Yerkovich will help you discover your love style and how to break free from negative patterns to create a deeper, richer marriage.

    Read more
  • Featured Initiative

    Focus on Marriage Assessment

    The Focus on the Family Marriage Assessment is designed to evaluate the strength of 12 essential traits of your marriage. Do you know your marriage’s strengths and weaknesses?

    Read more
  • Featured Article

    Melanie's Broccoli-Rice Casserole Recipe

    Melanie Shankle

    Melanie Shankle, guest on the Focus on the Family Daily Broadcast episode, "The Joys and Challenges of Marrying Your Opposite," shares her recipe for Broccoli-Rice Casserole.

    Read more
  • Featured Article

    Do Opposites Really Attract?

    Jim Daly

    Differences don't have to be obstacles to a healthy marriage. Your spouse's unique qualities are meant to complement your own. Appreciating the way the Lord has crafted your spouse will help you grow.

    Read more
More Episode Resources


Melanie Shankle

View Bio

Texas A&M graduate Melanie Shankle is a popular blogger and author of two books, Sparkly Green Earrings and The Antelope in the Living Room. She began her blog, Big Mama, in July 2006 and is also a regular contributor to The Pioneer Woman blog. Melanie lives in San Antonio, Texas with her husband, Perry, and daughter, Caroline.